罗杰艾伯特： Chicago Sun-Times (Roger Ebert) | |||
| 1 | Ballast | 11 | Iron Man |
| 2 | The Band's Visit | 12 | Milk |
| 3 | Che | 13 | Rachel Getting Married |
| 4 | Chop Shop | 14 | The Reader |
| 5 | The Dark Knight | 15 | Revolutionary Road |
| 6 | Doubt | 16 | Shotgun Stories |
| 7 | The Fall | 17 | Slumdog Millionaire |
| 8 | Frost/Nixon | 18 | Synecdoche, New York |
| 9 | Frozen River | 19 | W. |
| 10 | Happy-Go-Lucky | 20 | WALL-E |
| 娱乐周刊 Entertainment Weekly (Lisa Schwarzbaum) | |
| 1 | WALL-E |
| 2 | Milk |
| 3 | The Dark Knight |
| 4 | Waltz With Bashir |
| 5 | Gomorrah |
| 6 | Wendy & Lucy |
| 7 | Trouble the Water |
| 8 | Happy-Go-Lucky |
| 9 | Man on Wire |
| 10 | Tropic Thunder |
| Entertainment Weekly (Owen Gleiberman) | |
| 1 | The Wrestler |
| 2 | The Dark Knight |
| 3 | Rachel Getting Married |
| 4 | WALL-E |
| 5 | Momma's Man |
| 6 | The Edge of Heaven |
| 7 | Burn After Reading |
| 8 | The Class |
| 9 | Milk |
| 10 | Tell No One |
| 滚石 Rolling Stone (Peter Travers) | |
| 1 | Milk |
| 2 | Slumdog Millionaire |
| 3 | The Dark Knight |
| 4 | Frost/Nixon |
| 5 | WALL-E |
| 6 | Revolutionary Road |
| 7 | The Visitor |
| 8 | Doubt |
| 9 | Rachel Getting Married |
| 10 | Man on Wire |
| The New York Times (Stephen Holden) | |
| 1 | 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days |
| 2 | The Edge of Heaven |
| 3 | WALL-E |
| 4 | Milk |
| 5 | The Last Mistress |
| 6 | Happy-Go-Lucky |
| 7 | A Christmas Tale |
| 8 | Tell No One |
| 9 | Frozen River |
| 10 | The Visitor |
| 纽约时代 The New York Times (A.O. Scott) | |
| 1 | WALL-E |
| 2 | Silent Light |
| 3 | The Secret of the Grain |
| 4 | Man on Wire |
| 5 | The Edge of Heaven |
| 6 | Happy-Go-Lucky |
| 7 | Wendy and Lucy |
| 8 | Milk |
| 9 | Rachel Getting Married |
| 10 | Cadillac Records |
| The New York Times (Manohla Dargis) | |||
| 1 | Happy-Go-Lucky | ||
| 2 | Synechdoche, New York | ||
| 3 | Alexandra | ||
| 4 | Flight of the Red Balloon | ||
| 5 | Silent Light | ||
| 6 | Parnaoid Park | ||
| 7 | The Dark Knight | ||
| 8 | Encounters at the End of the World | ||
| 9 | Still Life | ||
| 10 | Wendy and Lucy | ||
| 纽约客 The New Yorker (Anthony Lane) | |
| 1 | WALL-E |
| 2 | Changeling |
| 3 | The Wrestler |
| 4 | Iron Man |
| 5 | Quantum of Solace |
| 6 | We Own the Night |
| 7 | I've Loved You So Long |
| 8 | Four Months, Three Weeks and Two Days |
| 9 | The Edge of Heaven |
| The Orphanage | |
| 新闻周刊 Newsweek (David Ansen) | |
| 1 | Let the Right One In |
| 2 | Encounters at the End of the World |
| 3 | Wendy and Lucy |
| 4 | Frost/Nixon |
| 5 | Man on Wire |
| 6 | Silent Light |
| 7 | The Wreslter |
| 8 | Tropic Thunder |
| 9 | WALL-E (tie) |
| Waltz With Bashir | |
| 洛杉矶时代 Los Angeles Times (Kenneth Turan) | |||
| 1 | Slumdog Millionaire | ||
| 2 | A Christmas Tale | (tie) | The Class |
| 3 | Frost/Nixon | ||
| 4 | Frozen River | (tie) | Ballast |
| 5 | Gomorrah | (tie) | Happy-Go-Lucky |
| 6 | Rachel Getting Married | ||
| 7 | Man On Wire | (tie) | Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired |
| 8 | Stranded | (tie) | Trouble the Water |
| Blindsight | (tie) | Pray the Devil Back | |
| Standard Operating Procedure | (tie) | Walk to Beautiful | |
| 9 | Tell No One | ||
| 10 | WALL-E | (tie) | Waltz With Bashir |
原帖由 井井回 于 2009-1-7 14:02 发表
9.男神与女神的罗曼史 Les amours d'Astrée et de Céladon，导演：Eric Rohmer，法国
侯麦已不是那个侯麦，德莱叶般的古典自然光
还是挺侯麦的，还是讲道德和男女。这次似乎完全不把现代人的恋爱观念放在眼里。 ...
原帖由 andsoon 于 2009-1-9 11:37 发表
什么叫“声画对位”？
原帖由 andsoon 于 2009-1-12 22:38 发表
我该问什么叫“声画‘不对位’”
原帖由 尚方翊剑 于 2009-1-13 19:56 发表
从“猴子”里举例，比如说儿子刚回到家时，注意环境音，你会听到轰隆的火车声，这时录音师录的混响非常大，明显不是这个空房间出来的，是声音的剪辑点。在比如说，你发现，在这个房子里窗户始终是打开的，而且它在车 ...
原帖由 冯与蓝 于 2009-1-7 19:24 发表
好在马上放假，一定要恶补~~
许鞍华的不管拍成啥样都必挺之！！！
| 欢迎光临 黑蓝论坛 (http://www.heilan.com/FORUM/) | Powered by Discuz! X2.5 |
